The shallow end on a Wednesday morning belongs to the women over seventy, and everybody at the pool knows it, and she is forty-one and she is in it with them, and Maureen has just told a joke about her late husband's dentures that has made the lifeguard put his hand over his face.
There are nine of them today. They walk widths, not lengths, in a loose line, talking the whole way, and the water takes the weight off knees and hips and one new shoulder, and they have been doing this longer than she has been alive. She was a runner. She ran the canal path every morning for eleven years and knew the herons by where they stood, and then the knee went, properly went, the surgeon's word was ended, and she cried in the parking lot of the physio's on a Tuesday in March in a way she had not cried since her father.
She called it the worst year of her life. She still calls it that, and she is not going to stop, because it was.
But Maureen has just asked, over the dentures, whether she is coming to Val's on Saturday, and she has said yes without checking, and standing there in the shallow end with the water at her waist she notices something she has been not-noticing for a while now. She cannot imagine her week without these women. And she cannot imagine the last two years without the slowness the knee forced on her: the walk to school with her son instead of the run past it, the fifteen minutes a day where he actually talked, the thing he told her on the towpath one October that she would have missed at running pace and that she is fairly sure changed his life. Nine women and a walking pace, out of the worst year, and she does not have a sentence for that. Every sentence she reaches for is a lie in one direction or the other. Either the knee was fine, which it was not, or she is glad it went, which she is not.
If you have a year like that, this is written for you, and let me be careful with you before I say anything, because this is the most dangerous page on this site. It is for the person on the far side, who has already noticed the good and does not know how to hold it next to the loss. If you are still inside the loss, if it is this year and not that year, then this page is not for today, and there is a room on this site for where you are, and I would rather you read that one. To the rest of you: I am not going to tell you the knee was sent. I am not going to tell you it was for the best. I am going to hand you two sentences instead of one, because one sentence is what has been choking you.
Two sentences, not one
Before Joseph, the word. This site sits under a name that sounds like a promise of comfort, and it is not one, so I will say plainly what blessed means before I use it near you: blessed is God's favor resting on a person, and it says nothing at all about whether their year improved. Jesus said it over the poor in spirit and over the mourning, to their faces, in the present tense. So when I say you are blessed in this, I do not mean the knee was a gift. I mean His face is toward you and His Spirit is with you, and that was so in the physio's parking lot as surely as it is in the shallow end.
Now the pit, honestly. The trouble with the good that came out of a bad year is that everybody wants you to collapse it into one sentence. The people who love you want the tidy one: see, it was all for a reason. And something in you refuses that sentence, because you were in the parking lot, and it was not a reason, it was a loss. So you have been holding the two things at arm's length from each other, and refusing to say either out loud, in case saying the good betrays the loss or saying the loss sounds ungrateful. And that silence has become its own weight.
Scripture does not make you choose. It has a man who says both, in one breath, to the faces of the people who caused it.
As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today.Genesis 50:20
Look at the grammar of that sentence, because the whole of this page is in it. Two subjects. You meant. God meant. Joseph does not say the pit was fine, or the slavery was a growth opportunity, or that his brothers did him a favor. He names the evil as evil, to the men who did it. And then, without taking one word of that back, he says God meant good, and the good is standing in front of them: people alive who would not be.
You are allowed both sentences, and it is not a loophole I found for you; it is written, in the mouth of a man who had more right to bitterness than most, and the Holy Spirit kept it in the book so that you could hold your knee in one hand and your Wednesdays in the other and not drop either. He is not the author of the harm. He is the one who redeemed it. Those are two different jobs and Scripture never confuses them.
He did not send the year; He was in it
Let me tell you what I have watched at the shelter I keep, because it is why I am so careful here. People arrive on the worst night of their lives. And later, sometimes much later, some of them find something in the aftermath they would not now trade: a friend from the next bed, a faith they did not have, a version of themselves they only met on the far side. And every one of them, at some point, asks me the same frightened question: does that mean it was supposed to happen? And I say no. Every time. It was not supposed to happen. And God was in it, and He has not wasted a single hour of it. Both.
Because here is where the comfortable lie lives, and it is more comfortable than the cruel one. The cruel lie says the year was punishment. The comfortable lie says the year was a gift in disguise, and you should be grateful for the injury because look what it brought. Both lies make God the author of the harm. Scripture does not. Scripture says He works all things together for good for those who love Him (Romans 8:28), and works together is a phrase about what He does with the materials, not a claim that He chose them all. A weaver is not the one who tore the cloth. He is the one who made the tear part of the pattern.
You have a God who redeems and does not merely permit, and that is not my hope for you but the plain witness of the word from Joseph to Romans, and the Holy Spirit is the one who has been doing the redeeming in your Wednesdays while you were busy not-noticing. The nine women were not the point of the knee. The knee had no point. The nine women are what He did with it.
So the sentence you have been unable to say is two sentences, and they go in this order. It was a loss, and I would never have chosen it. And God brought good out of it that I now cannot do without. Not one sentence with a because in the middle. Two, with a full stop between them, and the full stop is where the honesty lives.
Here is the turn, and it is not toward gratitude for the injury. It is toward permission.
You have permission, from Scripture and not from me, to stop collapsing your year into one sentence, and to say the two true ones out loud instead, and His Spirit is the one who makes the saying more than a technique. You do not owe anybody the tidy version. You do not have to say it was for the best to be allowed to love what came out of it. And you do not have to hate what came out of it to stay honest about the loss. Joseph did neither. He wept over the years and he pointed at the people alive, and God was in the second sentence and not the author of the first.
You are blessed, in the real sense, exactly where you are standing: in the shallow end, in a body that cannot run, with His favor resting on you as surely as it rested on you in the parking lot when nothing good was visible yet. Genesis 50:20 puts God's meaning on the far side of an evil it never excuses, and it is the Holy Spirit who has been doing the redeeming in the Wednesdays. The favor did not arrive with the women. It was there when there was only the knee.
Declare this over yourself
Say these where you can hear yourself, in the changing room, on the towpath, in the car. You are in Christ and Christ is in you, and the authority to say what a year was and what God did with it was given to you, not earned by having made peace with the year. Scripture is the ground under every line and the Holy Spirit is the one carrying it, not the confidence in your voice. And what He does with the rest of the road, whether more good comes out of it or the good you have is the whole of it, is His to decide, and none of it is a promise that the next hard year has a hidden gift in it, because that is not how the word reads. Say the two sentences.
- Knee that ended my running, you were a real loss and you were not sent to me as a lesson. It is written that what was meant for harm God meant for good, and He is not the author of what you cost me; He is the one who redeemed it.
- Pressure to make it one tidy sentence, you have had my mouth shut for two years and I hand you back in the name of Jesus. Joseph named the evil as evil and the good as God's in the same breath, and His Spirit gives me both sentences and the full stop between them.
- Lord, You did not send the year, and You were in every week of it, and You brought nine women and a walking pace out of what I would never have chosen. I thank You, because Your Spirit has been redeeming what I was busy not-noticing, and Your favor was on me in the parking lot before any of it was visible, exactly as it is written.
Genesis 50:20
This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.
